Skip to main content
Ultimate Creamy Fish Pie

Ultimate Creamy Fish Pie

with Peas, Leek and Baby Leaf Salad
Sam Richards
Sam RichardsUpdated on March 31, 2026
Calories
728 kcal
Protein
39.1g protein
Total
45 minutes
Difficulty
Easy
Allergens:
  • Fish
  • Celery
  • Milk
  • Mustard
  • Egg
  • Sulphites
Produced in a facility that processes eggs, milk, fish, peanuts, sesame, shellfish, soy, tree nuts, and wheat.
serving amount

450 grams

Potatoes

1 unit(s)

Leek

2 unit(s)

Garlic Clove

1 pack(s)

Fish Pie Mix

(Contains: Fish)

15 grams

Vegetable Stock Paste

(Contains: Celery)

75 grams

Creme Fraiche

(Contains: Milk)

17 grams

Wholegrain Mustard

(Contains: Mustard)

40 grams

Grated Hard Italian Style Cheese

(Contains: Milk, Egg)

120 grams

Peas

20 grams

Baby Leaf Mix

12 milliliter(s)

Balsamic Glaze

(Contains: Sulphites)

Not included in your delivery

30 grams

Butter

2 tbsp

Plain Flour

250 milliliter(s)

Water for the Sauce

Energy (kJ)3046 kJ
Energy (kcal)728 kcal
Fat34.7 g
of which saturates19.8 g
Carbohydrate69.7 g
of which sugars14.6 g
Dietary Fibre12 g
Protein39.1 g
Salt3.6 g
Trans Fat0.1 g
Always refer to the product label for the most accurate ingredient and allergen information.
Large Saucepan
Garlic Press
Fork
Oven dish
Potato Masher
Colander

Instructions

Cook the Potatoes
1

Bring a large saucepan of water with 1/2 tsp salt to the boil. 

Meanwhile, chop the potatoes into 2cm chunks (peel first if you prefer).

When boiling, add the potatoes to the water and cook until you can easily slip a knife through, 15-20 mins.

Fry the Leek
2

While the potatoes cook, trim the root and dark green leafy part from the leek and discard. Halve lengthways, then thinly slice. 

Heat a drizzle of oil in another large saucepan on medium-high heat.

Once hot, add the leek and season with salt and pepper. Cook, stirring occasionally, until softened, 4-6 mins.

Meanwhile, peel and grate the garlic (or use a garlic press). Drain the fish pie mix and pat dry with kitchen paper. IMPORTANT: Wash your hands and equipment after handling raw fish.

Start your Sauce
3

Once the leek has softened, add the garlic and cook for 30 secs more.

Add the butter (see pantry for amount) and allow it to melt, then stir in the flour (see pantry for amount). Cook, stirring continuously, for 1-2 mins. 

Stir in the water for the sauce (see pantry for amount) a little at a time, followed by the vegetable stock paste. Bring to the boil, then simmer, stirring occasionally, until thickened, 2-3 mins.

Poach the Fish
4

Once the sauce has thickened, stir in the creme fraiche, wholegrain mustard and half the hard Italian style cheese.

Next, gently stir through the fish pie mix.

Lower the heat and simmer gently, stirring occasionally, until the fish is cooked, 5-8 mins. IMPORTANT: The fish is cooked when opaque in the middle.

Meanwhile, heat your grill to high. 

Assemble your Pie
5

Once the potatoes are cooked, drain in a colander and return to the pan, off the heat. Add a knob of butter and a splash of milk (if you have any) and mash until smooth. Season with salt and pepper. 

Once the fish is cooked, stir through the peas. Cook until piping hot, 1-2 mins. Season with salt and pepper, then transfer to an ovenproof dish. 

Using a fork, spread the mash evenly over the filling, then sprinkle over the remaining cheese.

Grill and Serve
6

Grill your pie until the cheese has melted and is golden, 4-5 mins. 

Once ready, share the pie between your plates.

Serve the baby leaf salad alongside, drizzled with the balsamic glaze to finish.

Enjoy! 

Customer reviews

Review summary

Updated on Feb 2026
  • Flavour: Many enjoyed the delicate, balanced taste, though some found the mustard overpowering; consider reducing the amount for a milder flavour.
  • Ease of prep: The recipe was straightforward to follow, but spreading mash over hot sauce can be tricky; let the filling cool slightly first.
  • Suggestions: Add more fish or another vegetable like onion for extra substance. Some prefer peas in the pie rather than a side salad.
  • Portions: The dish was filling, with several mentioning there was enough for leftovers or to serve three people.
AI-generated from customer reviews

This week's must-try HelloFresh recipes