Skip to main content
Horrify, Terrify and Petrify Pie
Horrify, Terrify and Petrify Pie

Horrify, Terrify and Petrify Pie

Sharing Dish | with Cinnamon Spiced Apples and Plums

Serve up a fright this Halloween with our fiendishly flavoursome recipes. This pie may look a little horrifying, but with flaky pastry and cinnamon spiced apples and plums, it's terrifyingly tasty.

Allergens:
Gluten
Milk
Tree nuts

The quantities provided above are averages only.

Boxes and ingredients are packed in facilities that handles Peanut, Nuts, Sesame, Fish, Crustaceans, Milk, Egg, Mustard, Celery, Soya, Gluten and Sulphites. Due to the war in Ukraine, it has been necessary to substitute sunflower oil with rapeseed oil in some products without a label change. The FSA have advised that allergic reactions to rapeseed oil are rare.

Total1 hour
Active 25 minutes
DifficultyEasy

Ingredients

serving amount

1 pack(s)

Puff Pastry Sheet**

75 grams

Caster Sugar

3 unit(s)

Apple**

3 unit(s)

Plum**

2 sachet(s)

Ground Cinnamon

75 grams

Creme Fraiche**

15 grams

Toasted Flaked Almonds

Not included in your delivery

1 tbsp

Milk

Nutritional information

Energy (kJ)4366 kJ
Energy (kcal)1044 kcal
Fat55.3 g
of which saturates28.6 g
Carbohydrate126.2 g
of which sugars70.6 g
Dietary Fiber7.2 g
Protein12.8 g
Salt1.3 g
Potassium11.8 mg
Calcium9 mg
Always refer to the product label for the most accurate ingredient and allergen information.

Utensils

Rolling Pin
Cling Film
Baking Paper
Medium Saucepan
Small Bowl

Instructions

Rock and Roll
1

a) Preheat your oven to 220°C/200°C fan/gas mark 7 and remove your pastry from your fridge.

b) Unroll your pasty and cut it in half. Scrunch each half into a ball and then roll out each ball using a rolling pin to make a circle, about 2-4mm thick. TIP: To stop it sticking to your rolling pin, either dust with some flour or roll it out between some cling film or baking paper.

c) Cover one of the circles with cling film to stop it from drying out while you work with the other piece.

Into the Tin it Goes
2

a) Line an 8" round tin with baking paper.

b) Carefully lift one of the dough circles into the lined tin and gently press down into the bottom edges of the tin. TIP: Lift the top edges of the pastry as you press it into the tin to ensure it doesn't break.

c) Carefully trim away any excess pastry. TIP: If any cracks have appeared in your pastry case in this step, use excess dough to fill the cracks by pressing them into the pastry.

d) Using a fork, prick holes in the bottom of your pastry. TIP: We recommend pricking it 20-30 times.

Blind Bake the Pastry
3

a) Scrunch up a large piece of baking paper, then un-scrunch and place into the centre of your pastry case.

b) Fill the baking paper topped pastry case with ceramic baking beans, ensuring the baking beans cover the whole base of your case. TIP: If you don't have ceramic baking beans, you can use uncooked rice or lentils.

c) Pop your pastry case onto the middle shelf of your oven. Bake for 15-20 mins, then gently remove the ceramic baking beans and the baking paper. TIP: This method is called 'blind baking'. The ceramic baking beans will be hot!

d) Return the pastry case to the oven until the bottom is lightly golden, 8-12 mins.

Prep the Filling
4

a) While the pastry cooks, reserve 1 tbsp of caster sugar in a small bowl and set aside for later.

b) Quarter, core and finely chop the apples (no need to peel). Halve the plums, remove the stone and chop the flesh into 1cm pieces.

c) Heat a medium saucepan on medium heat. When hot, add the plums, apples, remaining caster sugar and cinnamon to the pan.

d) Cook, stirring regularly, until the apple and plums begin to soften and the liquid has evaporated, 10-12 mins.

Make the Scary Face
5

a) Meanwhile, using a small knife, cut a spooky face into the reserved pastry circle. Make sure the mouth is nice and wide so its teeth fit in later!

b) Once the pastry is finished baking, add the spiced apple and plum mixture to the tin and top with the pastry face.

c) Carefully trim away any excess pastry, then brush with milk (see pantry for amount) and sprinkle over the reserved sugar.

It's Alive!
6

a) Pop the pie onto the middle shelf of your oven and bake until the fruit is bubbling and the pastry is crisp and golden, 12- 15 mins. Turn the tin around halfway through to give a nice, even colour. TIP: Put the tin onto a baking tray to catch any drips.

b) Once cooked, allow to cool for at least 15 mins, then add some flaked almonds around the inside of the mouth to make the teeth.

c) Carefully remove your pie from the tin. Serve with a dollop of creme fraiche on the side to finish.

Enjoy!

Meal right image

Explore Similar Recipes

Meal left image

This week's must-try HelloFresh recipes

Greek Style Chicken and Halloumi BBQ Skewers

Greek Style Chicken and Halloumi BBQ Skewers

with Flatbreads, Parsley Yoghurt and Baby Gem Salad
Korean Inspired Gochujang Pork Belly and Sesame Pear Slaw

Korean Inspired Gochujang Pork Belly and Sesame Pear Slaw

with Sambal Rice and Cucumber Salad
Char Siu Udon and Sweet Chilli Veggie Gyozas

Char Siu Udon and Sweet Chilli Veggie Gyozas

with Soy-Sesame Broccoli, Mushrooms and Peanut-Coriander Gremolata
Make your own Curry Paste: Butternut Butter Masala

Make your own Curry Paste: Butternut Butter Masala

with Peas, Cashew Nuts and Rice
Seared Monkfish Medallions on Lemon Risotto

Seared Monkfish Medallions on Lemon Risotto

with Homemade Bacon Jam and Rocket Salad
Homemade Lamb Keema Pau

Homemade Lamb Keema Pau

with Mango Chutney, Pickled Onion and Salad
Quick Goulash Inspired Beef

Quick Goulash Inspired Beef

with Bulgur Wheat, Bell Pepper and Soured Cream
Jerk Style Spatchcock Chicken and Pineapple Chutney

Jerk Style Spatchcock Chicken and Pineapple Chutney

with Coconut Rice & Beans, Slaw and Tenderstem®
Mozzarella and Roasted Butternut Squash Salad

Mozzarella and Roasted Butternut Squash Salad

with Rocket, Pesto Dressing and Croutons
Crispy Onion Topped BBQ Hot Dogs and Chips

Crispy Onion Topped BBQ Hot Dogs and Chips

with Burger Sauce Slaw and Rocket
Homemade Jamaican Style Curried Beef Patties

Homemade Jamaican Style Curried Beef Patties

with Roasted Pepper and Pickled Onion Salad
Thai Style Chicken Spaghetti

Thai Style Chicken Spaghetti

with Pepper, Spinach and Peanuts
Biang Biang Inspired Hand-Cut Noodles in Hoisin Sauce

Biang Biang Inspired Hand-Cut Noodles in Hoisin Sauce

with Stir-Fried Veg and Crushed Peanuts
Caribbean Style Spiced Salmon

Caribbean Style Spiced Salmon

with Kiwi Salsa, Chips and Zesty Slaw
Easy Peasy Chorizo Linguine

Easy Peasy Chorizo Linguine

with Peas and Balsamic Glaze
Chinese Style BBQ Pork Steak

Chinese Style BBQ Pork Steak

with Sesame Chips, Asparagus and Garlicky Tenderstem® Broccoli
Middle Eastern Style Lamb and Couscous

Middle Eastern Style Lamb and Couscous

with Roasted Cumin Carrots and Yoghurt
Chipotle Chicken Fajita Traybake

Chipotle Chicken Fajita Traybake

with Soured Cream and Baby Leaf Salad
Thai Style Coconut Fried Chicken and Green Curry Mayo

Thai Style Coconut Fried Chicken and Green Curry Mayo

with Sweet Chilli Bacon Smashed Potatoes, Mango and Coriander Salad
21 Day Aged Rump Steak and Crispy Parmesan Gnocchi

21 Day Aged Rump Steak and Crispy Parmesan Gnocchi

with Spiced Chorizo Salsa and Tenderstem®