Skip to main content
Log in
Log in
Mystical Mornings Chocolate & Peanut Butter Overnight Oats

Mystical Mornings Chocolate & Peanut Butter Overnight Oats

with Chocolate Chips and Salted Caramel Drizzle
3.5(123)Review Summary
Recipe Development Team
Recipe Development TeamUpdated on January 12, 2026
Get 50% off your first box & free treats for 2 months!
Get 50% off your first box & free treats for 2 months!
Calories
: 
922 kcal
Protein
: 
21.1g protein
Difficulty
: 
Easy
Allergens:
  • Peanut
  • Milk
  • Cereals containing gluten
  • Soya
  • May contain traces of allergens
  • Nuts
  • Milk
  • Soya
  • Cereals containing gluten
Produced in a facility that processes eggs, milk, fish, peanuts, sesame, shellfish, soy, tree nuts, and wheat.
serving amount

60 grams

Peanut Butter

(Contains: May contain traces of allergens, Nuts, Peanut)

80 grams

Salted Caramel Sauce

(Contains: Milk)

75 grams

Creme Fraiche

(Contains: Milk)

120 grams

Instant Oats

(Contains: Cereals containing gluten, Milk, Soya, May contain traces of allergens, Cereals containing gluten, Nuts)

100 grams

Chocolate Chips

(Contains: Soya, Milk, May contain traces of allergens)

Not included in your delivery

150 milliliter(s)

Water

Energy (kJ)3857 kJ
Energy (kcal)922 kcal
Fat49.8 g
of which saturates21.5 g
Carbohydrate93.7 g
of which sugars52.1 g
Protein21.1 g
Salt0.4 g
Always refer to the product label for the most accurate ingredient and allergen information.
•Bowl

Instructions

PDF
Get Prepped
1

a) In a mixing bowl, add the peanut butter and three-quarters of the salted caramel sauce, then mix to combine.

b) Slowly add the creme fraiche, stirring continuously, until fully combined.

c) Repeat this step with the water (see pantry for amount).

Time to Chill
2

a) Add the instant oats, three-quarters of the chocolate chips and a pinch of salt to the peanut caramel mixture, then stir well to combine.

b) Cover with cling film and pop in the fridge for at least 4 hours or ideally overnight for the best texture!

Finish and Serve
3

a) When you're ready to eat, give the oats another good stir.

b) Divide the overnight oats between 2 serving bowls. 

c) Drizzle over the remaining salted caramel sauce and sprinkle over the remaining chocolate chips to finish. 

Enjoy!

Customer reviews

Review summary

Updated on Feb 2026
  • Flavour: Many found it deliciously creamy, though some felt it was overly sweet and rich for breakfast.
  • Ease of prep: Quick and easy to prepare, with convenient overnight chilling for a ready-made morning meal.
  • Suggestions: Consider reducing peanut butter, chocolate, and caramel amounts; add sliced banana or fruit coulis for balance.
  • Portions: Very filling; some found a half portion satisfying due to richness.
  • Consistency: For a less stodgy texture, try adding more liquid or reducing the oats slightly.
AI-generated from customer reviews
Meal right image

Explore Our Meal Kits

Food Box
Weekly Menu
Meal Boxes for 1 Person
Vegetarian Meal Delivery
Calorie Smart Meal Delivery
Family Food Boxes
Meal left image

More delicious recipes with similar ingredients

Creamy Cajun Beef Rigatoni

with Spinach and Cheese

Creamy Cajun Spiced Chorizo Orzo

with Peas and Toasted Breadcrumb Topping

Creamy Sausage and Butter Bean Cassoulet

with Baby Spinach and Ciabatta

Creamy Gochujang Beef Rigatoni

with Spinach and Spring Onion

Spicy Creamy Cajun Chicken Pasta

with Cheese

Creamy Bacon Pesto Pasta

with Peas and Grated Hard Italian Style Cheese

Rosemary Lamb and Mushroom Rigatoni

with Creamy Sauce and Cheese

Pork Meatballs in Creamy Chive Sauce

with Chips and Green Beans

Herby Lemon and Prawn Linguine

with Peas and Parsley

Prince Harry's Chicken Pie

with Mushrooms and Roasted Carrots

Sea Bass on Creamy Linguine

with Burst Tomatoes and Garlic Crumb

Chicken in Creamy Peppercorn Sauce

with Mash and Roasted Chantenay Carrots

Creamy Pesto Pasta

with Peas, Spinach and Cheese

Pan-Fried Venison Steaks

with Rosemary Potatoes and Creamy Mustard Sauce

Creamy Prawn & Bacon Spaghetti

with Garlic and Green Chilli

Serrano Ham Wrapped Chicken

with Cheesy Truffled Roast Potatoes and Roasted Tenderstem®

Presto Bacon and Mushroom Linguine

with Asparagus

Creamy Mushroom Pasta

with Balsamic Dressed Rocket

Chicken and Mushroom Crumble

with Basmati Rice

Speedy Creamy Chorizo & Sweetcorn Pasta

with Spinach

Highest-rated dinner recipes

Pan-Fried Venison Steaks

with Rosemary Potatoes and Creamy Mustard Sauce

BBQ Pulled Chicken Loaded Cheesy Fries

with Fresh Avocado, Coriander and Chilli Salsa

Roasted Pork Medallion

with Sweet Potato Mash and Peppercorn Sauce

Teriyaki Salmon Poke Style Bowl

with Jasmine Rice, Sugarsnaps and Lime Chilli Kiwi Salsa

Prawn and Chorizo Spaghetti

with Fresh Tomato Sauce and Chilli

Creamy Mushroom Pasta

with Balsamic Dressed Rocket

Serrano Ham Wrapped Chicken

with Cheesy Truffled Roast Potatoes and Roasted Tenderstem®

Honey Glazed Halloumi Gyros

with Sweet Potato Fries & Tzatziki Inspired Salad

Honey Glazed Chicken Flatbread

With Sweet Potato Feta Wedges, Harissa Veg and Pickled Red Onion

Refried Bean and Halloumi Tacos

with Chipotle Mayo

Chicken and Mushroom Crumble

with Basmati Rice

Creamy Cajun Beef Rigatoni

with Spinach and Cheese

Creamy Gochujang Beef Rigatoni

with Spinach and Spring Onion

Halloumi & Sweet Potato Dal

with Mango Chutney & Naan Bread

Chipotle Beef Rigatoni

with Cheddar and Spinach

Thai Style Pork Rice Bowl

with Green Beans, Coriander and Rice

Cheeseburger Loaded Fries

with Tomatoes, Caramelised Onion and Burger Sauce

Super Cheesy Oven-Baked Tomato Risotto

with Rocket Salad

Chermoula Spiced Lamb and Rice

With Tzatziki

Pan-Fried Chicken

with Spicy Lentils

This week's must-try HelloFresh recipes

Orzo Mac and Cheese

with Sweet Potato, Spinach and Sriracha

Lychee Style Pork in Sweet and Sour Cherry Sauce

with Rice and Pepper

Cantonese Style Hoisin Chicken Noodles

with Pepper, Green Beans and Sesame Seeds

Chicken Schnitzel and Mushroom Guinness® Gravy

with Chips and Balsamic Dressed Baby Leaf Salad

Mediterranean Style Chicken and Ditali Pasta Salad

with Roasted Chickpeas and Cheese

Yi Mein Inspired Longevity Noodles

with Portobello Mushrooms, Spring Onion and Crispy Onions

Spiced Butternut Wedges and Honey-Harissa Sauce

with Buttery Cabbage and Roasted Potatoes

Smoky Cod and Mexican Style Spiced Sauce

with Bell Pepper, Spinach and Steamed Rice

Curried Sweet Potato and Lentil Pie

with Baby Spinach and Mango Chutney

BBQ Jerk Spiced Halloumi and Couscous Bowl

with Pickled Onion and Charred Veg

Charred Courgette, Pea and Mint Salad

with Greek Style Cheese, Croutons, Pickled Onions and Yoghurt Drizzle

Spiced Tofu, Sweet Potato and Avocado Salad

with Lime, Garlic Soured Cream Dressing and Rocket

Classic Meat-Free Mince Spag Bol

with Cheese, Mushrooms and Wild Rocket

Swedish Style Creamy Dill Chicken

with Sautéed Mushrooms, Buttery Cabbage and Mashed Potato

Mediterranean Style Houmous and Beetroot Bowl

with Crispy Chickpeas, Tomato and Croutons

One Pan Gochujang Beef Udon

with Soy, Garlic, Mushrooms and Roasted Sesame

Homemade Lamb Keema Pau

with Mango Chutney, Pickled Onion, Baby Cucumber and Salad

Weeknight Sticky Honey Pork Rice Bowl

with Pak Choi and Peanuts

Sri Lankan Style Devilled Paneer

with Pepper, Basmati Rice and Homemade Mango Sambol

Creamy Mushroom, Spinach & Ricotta Tortelloni

with Balsamic Glaze and Rocket Salad