Skip to main content
Creamy Chicken and Mushroom Pie
Creamy Chicken and Mushroom Pie

Creamy Chicken and Mushroom Pie

with Potato Topping and Roasted Carrots

Recipe Development Team
Recipe Development TeamUpdated on September 20, 2025

This Creamy Chicken and Mushroom Pie is perfect for the colder months. We're serving this classic combination with a hotpot inspired topping of thinly sliced potatoes under cheesy breadcrumbs. Best served when baked until golden and delicious.

Tags:
High Protein
Allergens:
Wheat
Cereals containing gluten
Milk
Egg

The quantities provided above are averages only.

Boxes and ingredients are packed in facilities that handles Peanut, Nuts, Sesame, Fish, Crustaceans, Milk, Egg, Mustard, Celery, Soya, Gluten and Sulphites. Due to the war in Ukraine, it has been necessary to substitute sunflower oil with rapeseed oil in some products without a label change. The FSA have advised that allergic reactions to rapeseed oil are rare.

Total45 minutes
Active 20 minutes
DifficultyMedium

Ingredients

serving amount

1 unit(s)

Baking Potato

2 unit(s)

Garlic Clove

4 unit(s)

British Chicken Thighs

3 unit(s)

Carrot

25 grams

Breadcrumbs

(Contains: Wheat, Cereals containing gluten)

80 grams

Sliced Mushrooms

10 grams

Chicken Stock Paste

150 grams

Creme Fraiche

(Contains: Milk)

20 grams

Grated Hard Italian Style Cheese

(Contains: Milk, Egg)

Not included in your delivery

2 tbsp

Olive Oil for the Crumb

50 milliliter(s)

Water for the Sauce

1 tbsp

Honey

Nutritional information

Energy (kJ)4466 kJ
Energy (kcal)1067 kcal
Fat62.3 g
of which saturates25.8 g
Carbohydrate65 g
of which sugars19.3 g
Dietary Fibre8.6 g
Protein57.2 g
Salt2.06 g
Always refer to the product label for the most accurate ingredient and allergen information.

Utensils

Garlic Press
Colander
Large Saucepan
Bowl
Pan
Baking Tray
Oven dish

Cooking Instructions and Tips

Get Prepped
1

Preheat your oven to 220°C/200°C fan/gas mark 7. Bring a large saucepan of water with ½ tsp salt to the boil.

Peel the potato and slice into 1cm thick rounds.

Once boiling, add the potato slices to the water and simmer until you can easily slip a knife through, 8-12 mins. Carefully drain in a colander and set aside.

Peel and grate the garlic (or use a garlic press). Cut each chicken thigh into 2cm chunks. IMPORTANT: Wash your hands and equipment after handling raw chicken and its packaging.

Brown the Chicken
2

While the potatoes cook, heat a drizzle of oil in a frying pan on medium-high heat.

Once hot, add the chicken, season with salt and pepper and cook until browned all over, 3-4 mins. Turn occasionally.

Transfer the browned chicken to a bowl and set aside.

Roast the Carrots
3

Trim the carrots, then halve lengthways (no need to peel). Chop into roughly 1cm wide, 5cm long batons. 

Pop the carrots onto a large baking tray. Drizzle with oil, season with salt and pepper, then toss to coat. Spread out in a single layer. Roast on the middle shelf of your oven until tender, 25-30 mins. Turn halfway through.

In a small bowl, combine the breadcrumbs and olive oil for the crumb (see pantry for amount). Season with salt and pepper and set aside.

 

Simmer the Sauce
4

Return the (now empty) frying pan to medium-high heat with a drizzle of oil. Once hot, add the mushrooms to the pan. Season with salt and pepper and fry until browned, 5-6 mins, stirring occasionally. Stir in the garlic and cook for 1 min.

Add the water for the sauce (see pantry for amount) and chicken stock paste. Return the browned chicken to the pan, then bring to the boil.

Bake the Hotpot
5

Mix in the creme fraiche and cheese, then turn down the heat and simmer until thickened, 3-4 mins.

Transfer the pie filling to an appropriately sized ovenproof dish. Layer on the cooked potato slices. Season with salt and pepper, then sprinkle over the crumb. Bake on the top shelf of your oven until golden brown, 15-20 mins. IMPORTANT: The chicken is cooked when no longer pink in the middle.

When the carrots have 5 mins remaining, remove the tray from the oven. Drizzle over the honey (see pantry for amount), then return to the oven for the remaining time.

Finish and Serve
6

When ready, serve your chicken and mushroom pie on plates with the roasted carrots alongside.

This week's must-try HelloFresh recipes

Teriyaki Pulled Beef Bao

Teriyaki Pulled Beef Bao

with Black Sesame Wedges and Smacked Cucumber Salad
Peri Peri & Maple Glazed Spatchcock Chicken

Peri Peri & Maple Glazed Spatchcock Chicken

with Chips, Garlic Bread, Peas and Tenderstem® Broccoli
Ultimate Beef and Chorizo Lasagne Soup

Ultimate Beef and Chorizo Lasagne Soup

with Herby Garlic Bread
Chinese BBQ Style Roast Pork Belly and Sticky Rice

Chinese BBQ Style Roast Pork Belly and Sticky Rice

with Roasted Greens, Spring Rolls and Sweet Chilli Sauce
Ultimate Creamy Truffle Mushroom & Burrata Linguine

Ultimate Creamy Truffle Mushroom & Burrata Linguine

with Flaked Almonds, Rocket Salad and Garlic Ciabatta
American Style Chicken Schnitzel Sando

American Style Chicken Schnitzel Sando

with Caramelised Onions, Burger Sauce, Apple Slaw and Fries
Cosy Butternut Squash Mac and Cheese

Cosy Butternut Squash Mac and Cheese

with Rocket and a Crispy Sage Crumb
Orkney Crab, Leek and Potato Gratin

Orkney Crab, Leek and Potato Gratin

with Oven-Ready Garlic Baguette and Baby Plum Tomato Salad
Chilli non Carne Rice Jumble

Chilli non Carne Rice Jumble

with Bell Pepper, Soured Cream, Avocado and Coriander
Smoky Harissa Butter Beans and Toasted Ciabatta

Smoky Harissa Butter Beans and Toasted Ciabatta

with Roasted Sweet Potato, Greek Style Cheese and Crispy Onions
Creamy Chickpea Korma

Creamy Chickpea Korma

with Basmati Rice, Peas and Coriander
Harissa Butter Bean Loaded Jacket Potato

Harissa Butter Bean Loaded Jacket Potato

with Greek Style Cheese and Radish & Baby Leaf Salad
Greek Style Lamb Moussaka

Greek Style Lamb Moussaka

with Creamy Aubergine Topping
Pesto Pulled Chicken Orzo

Pesto Pulled Chicken Orzo

with Spinach, Peas and Cheese
Mexican Style Bacon and Bean Frijoles Charros

Mexican Style Bacon and Bean Frijoles Charros

with Soured Cream and Cheese
Peri Peri Spiced Chicken Thigh Traybake

Peri Peri Spiced Chicken Thigh Traybake

with Roast Potatoes and Tomato & Baby Leaf Salad
Family Favourite Pork and Apple Burger

Family Favourite Pork and Apple Burger

with Rosemary Wedges and Rocket Salad
Mozzarella and Roasted Butternut Squash Salad

Mozzarella and Roasted Butternut Squash Salad

with Rocket, Pesto Dressing and Croutons
Midweek Chipotle Beef and Pork Rigatoni

Midweek Chipotle Beef and Pork Rigatoni

with Cheddar, Spinach and Rocket
Creamy Bacon, Potato and Baby Gem Salad

Creamy Bacon, Potato and Baby Gem Salad

with Ciabatta Croutons and Italian Style Cheese